Pale Carnations
by DrDetroitπ 23
A pre-med good boy, a high-class club, and a big titty goth GF. Deep gooning, deep storytelling, and choices that actually count.
The Setup
Some deep gooning, deep storytelling, and a really nice plot. That's Pale Carnations in a sentence.
You play a pre-med student who's trying to stay on the straight and narrow, until your best friend gets you a job at a high-class club. And by "club", I mean the sort of establishment where the clientele are very wealthy and the staff are very accommodating. Who can blame him for taking the job, really, med school isn't going to pay for itself.
Story & Characters
The MC is a little cucky to start with. BUT, you can shape him into the most or the least debauched person in the game. He can be Chad McChaddington, or Cuck Cuckerson of Cuckville. That's the beauty of this game. CHOICE!
Obviously, we all want a big titty goth GF, and this game gives you the option of exactly that. Hana Rhodes is the hard, cold daughter of one of the owners, and you can melt her by acting like a hero, even if you're actually just enjoying yourself. Better still, there's a route where you can get a free pass to bone other women, which is exactly what we want to hear. No guilt, just pure harem building.
Killian, your best friend, is the one who gets you the job, along with his uncle. I assumed he'd be annoying at first, and he does make annoying comments and choices, but even he's got a three-dimensional backstory. You end up feeling a bit sorry for him.
Then there are the three Carnations themselves, Rosalind, Veronica and Felicia. They've all got nicely fleshed-out backstories and are decent characters in their own right. Allowed to flourish and properly supported, you can both enjoy them sexually and have them feel all the right ways about you.
Art & Animation
Mutt & Jeff have done a really good job with the graphics. The scenes are well composed, and in spite of how long they've been making it, the quality has stayed high. There are nearly 700 animations in there at this point, which tells you how seriously they take it.
The Gooning
It's hot. There's just the right balance of domination and toeing the line, the right level of standing up for yourself and independence, with some nice deeper, darker backstories underneath.
The balance between talking and doing is just right, too. You could argue there's a lot of "waffle", and fair enough, the game is over 640,000 words, which is longer than War and Peace, and I can't remember Tolstoy getting anyone sucked off. But the H-scenes are deep, long, and hard (lol).
The story is maybe a little less deep than Eternum's, but it's a very nice balance. They haven't forgotten the three requirements of any adult story: bewbs, boning, and bitches.
Gameplay
Choices seem to matter. Whether you're liked or disliked, and what happens with certain characters, does seem to reflect what you've chosen.
It earns all that reading by landing the plot points in the right places, and giving you enough H-scenes to pace them out. It can get a little sloggy from time to time, and it can feel a bit heavy on the clicking. But it doesn't disappoint when it then rewards you by getting you sucked off by your big titty goth GF in da club.
The Verdict
The plot is what sets it apart. It's a really nice way to get you debauched and in control of your own destiny, while delivering a genuinely erotic plot at the same time.
It's still in development, and I played Chapter 4 Update 5. But it's free on itch, and all itch games are basically the same: you take a punt, and if it never finishes, that's disappointing, but it's not something you can really cry about when it didn't cost you anything.
Mutt & Jeff know how to make a quality sex game.
TL;DR
Deep gooning, deep story, and real choice over who you become. Free, and one of the best on the site.



