goongames.gg

Carnal Instinct

by DrDetroit👁 217

Early Access

A genuinely good-looking furry RPG that's going to take a LONG time to cross the finish line.

The Setup

If you've ever wondered what it would be like to be a bipedal big cat with a large wang, going around banging other bipedal humanoid animals, this is the game for you.

Carnal Instinct is a 3D open-world action RPG built in Unreal Engine, which already makes it a bit of an odd one out round here. The God-Queen Kethra hasn't been seen for a thousand years, eight demigods now rule the land of Sabu as warlords, and you enter the world as a slave. Where it goes from there... well... I'm honestly still not sure, and that's going to be the running thread through this whole review.

Story & Characters

The story, as it stands, is fractal. Bits here, bits there, nothing particularly connected. It reads like the Patreon votes every month and goes "finish this bit over here", then "now finish that little bit over there", then "ooh, those shiny colours look good this month". I can see it becoming a decent story eventually, but there is very little coherent questing in the game at present. You get fragments of quests every so often, and that's about it. If a proper RPG's main quest runs 20 to 40 hours, before you even get to the side quests, it feels like we're still somewhere in the first quarter.

Companions? So far, none. I've not seen any.

The character creator, on the other hand, is not short of options. I went feline initially, but now I'm a void sister. You can pick formless, human, demi-felian, full felian, demi-draconid, draconid, demi-jackal, full jackal, crocodilian, monstrous or void-sister. Whatever your particular flavour of furry, they've probably got you covered, and if you get bored, you just go back to the shrine and mix it up.

Art & Animation

It does earn the "quality visuals" billing. HOWEVER, it needs a lot of optimisation. You need a pretty decent rig to run it. My 3080 heats up like a bastard, I've had to drop everything down to High just to avoid issues, and with an i9 in there too, the whole PC turns into an oven. Anyone running it on a crappy rig is going to have a bad time.

The sex animations are OK. There are what the devs call "DLSS scenes" and standard interaction scenes, and they're slightly different, with different levels of control. They're not uncanny valley, but they aren't constant either.

The Gooning

The game is decent quality, what there is of it, and the sex scenes are crafted well. You can go back and re-run the repeatable sex interactions, but the story scenes are isolated things. It's not NOT goon material. It's just a different type of goon material.

Gameplay

The combat is a bit clunky. There's a lot of rolling out of the way and hammering a mouse button.

The world is still quite empty. Outside a couple of populated areas, it's mostly sparse open desert rather than somewhere that feels worth exploring. I've completed what's there, so my routine every update is: load it up, find the missions they've added, go there, get them, complete them, exit the game. Starting fresh, I reckon you'd get about 10 hours out of it.

There are bugs. Every time it updates, I get a persistent error claiming my CPU is having issues, which goes away once I clear the nVidia caches. It also re-draws its shaders every update, which, fine, I get it. The menus are clunky and sometimes lag out. And, as I said, it's a resource hog.

The Verdict

I'll give them a lot of credit for the effort. Trying to make a proper, full RPG sex game, rather than another click-through visual novel, is a big (sex) swing. Whether it's a swing that knocks it out of the park, or a swing and a miss in the grand scheme, is between you, your wallet, and your willingness to gamble. We've seen this pattern before with RSI's Star Citizen: hundreds of millions in, a far bigger dev team, and it's STILL not finished. If Carnal Instinct ever starts doing the Star Citizen thing of "we'll sell you a special wang for $20", escape whilst you can.

BUT, this is a VERY slow development. Or maybe it just feels slow because we're watching it happen in real time. The developers flipped from UE4 to UE5 a year or so in, and basically started again from scratch. Personally, I'd never have done that. The UE4 version was much further forward, so I'd have finished it, then made Carnal Instinct 2 on UE5. Since the switch, the releases have mostly been "here are two or three more missions", and that's how it's been for the last three or four updates.

My feedback would be: build the world out, then build missions in bulk. Or build tooling that allows quick mission building, then craft the sex scenes to fit. But I'm not a game developer. All I know is that at three or four missions every four or five months, we're going to be here a LONG time.

Then there's the release model. Updates go to the highest Patreon tier first, then the middle tiers, then the lower tiers, then Steam, a week apart each, so a release takes about a month to trickle down. The week after that, there's a patch to fix it all. It's painfully slow, and there are periods where it feels like the creator is dragging things out. What they want, clearly, is constant funding via Patreon. It's the eternal dilemma of the Patreon model.

If I had my choice again, I'd be on the fence about buying it on Steam. It's a game where the sex is part of the plot, but the plot only partially exists.

The big fix? Stop listening to the whims of Patreon and get the game finished. Push through the slog of making missions, and if you need to hire more people, do so. Otherwise this game isn't going to be finished, or good, in the next three years.

TL;DR

It's decent — real credit for attempting a proper full RPG sex game, BUT if they keep chasing the whims of Patreon over the people who just want a finished game, you'll get years of cruft before you get anything coherent.

Rate this game

Log in to rate and review.

Comments

Log in to comment.

No comments yet.

If you like this…

goongames.gg

Adults only — 18+

This site contains explicit adult content. You must be 18 or older (or the age of majority in your jurisdiction) to enter.

Leave

By entering you confirm you are of legal age to view adult material where you live.